Best MLB Playoff Roster Rankings in MLB The Show 25

Best MLB Playoff Roster Rankings in MLB The Show 25

Updated: October 08,2025 | Game: MLB THE SHOW
Best MLB Playoff Roster Rankings in MLB The Show 25

1. Overview of the MLB Playoffs and MLB The Show 25

As the MLB postseason intensifies, baseball enthusiasts have a perfect excuse to revisit MLB The Show 25. The excitement of October baseball brings anticipation, surprise, and the thrill of competition that engages fans and gamers alike. This year, we witness the clash of some of the finest teams in baseball, leading to a user-friendly experience within the game as we assess the rosters.

MLB The Show 25 has continuously evolved, with roster updates impacting player ratings significantly. The latest adjustments reflect the most current and authentic assessments of MLB talent. This update process not only enhances gameplay but also allows us to evaluate which of the remaining playoff teams has the best roster according to MLB The Show.

2. Top Teams and Rosters

Below, we delve into each of the final eight teams in the MLB playoffs, reviewing their rosters, starting pitchers, and average overall ratings. Understanding these stats can help players make informed decisions when purchasing MLB The Show 25 stubs to enhance their gaming experience.

1: Los Angeles Dodgers

Pitchers

  • SP Yoshinobu Yamamoto, 95
  • SP Shohei Ohtani, 98
  • SP Blake Snell, 94
  • SP Tyler Glasnow, 89
  • SP Clayton Kershaw, 83
  • SP Emmet Sheehan, 83

Lineup

1: DH Shohei Ohtani, 98
2: SS Mookie Betts, 87
3: RF Teoscar Hernandez, 83
4: 1B Freddie Freeman, 89
5: 2B Tommy Edman, 84
6: 3B Max Muncy, 87
7: LF Alex Call, 75
8: CF Andy Pages, 88
9: C Will Smith, 95

Average Overall

  • Starting pitchers: 90.3
  • Starting lineup: 87.3
  • Full team: 84

2: New York Yankees

Pitchers

  • SP Max Fried, 89
  • SP Carlos Rodon, 89
  • SP Cam Schlittler, 84
  • SP Luis Gil, 76
  • SP Will Warren, 76

Lineup

1: CF Trent Grisham, 85
2: RF Aaron Judge, 99
3: LF Cody Bellinger, 94
4: 1B Ben Rice, 82
5: DH Giancarlo Stanton, 84
6: 2B Jazz Chisholm, 90
7: 3B Ryan McMahon, 73
8: SS Anthony Volpe, 77
9: C Austin Wells, 80

Average Overall

  • Starting pitchers: 82.8
  • Starting lineup: 84.9
  • Full team: 79.7

3: Seattle Mariners

Pitchers

  • SP Luis Castillo, 83
  • SP George Kirby, 86
  • SP Logan Gilbert, 90
  • SP Bryce Miller, 70
  • SP Emerson Hancock, 60

Lineup

1: LF Randy Arozarena, 78
2: C Cal Raleigh, 99
3: CF Julio Rodriguez, 91
4: 2B Jorge Polanco, 83
5: 3B Eugenio Suarez, 90
6: 1B Josh Naylor, 83
7: DH Mitch Garver, 70
8: RF Victor Robles, 72
9: SS J.P. Crawford, 77

Average Overall

  • Starting pitchers: 77.8
  • Starting lineup: 82.6
  • Full team: 77.3

4: Chicago Cubs

Pitchers

  • SP Matthew Boyd, 80
  • SP Shota Imanaga, 81
  • SP Jameson Taillon, 79
  • SP Colin Rea, 76
  • SP Aaron Civale, 69

Lineup

1: 1B Michael Busch, 84
2: 2B Nico Hoerner, 89
3: DH Kyle Tucker, 89
4: RF Seiya Suzuki, 89
5: LF Ian Happ, 81
6: C Carson Kelly, 84
7: CF Pete Crow-Armstrong, 93
8: SS Dansby Swanson, 87
9: 3B Matt Shaw, 74

Average Overall

  • Starting pitchers: 76.8
  • Starting lineup: 85.6
  • Full team: 81.5

5: Philadelphia Phillies

Pitchers

  • SP Christopher Sanchez, 93
  • SP Aaron Nola, 75
  • SP Jesus Luzardo, 85
  • SP Ranger Suarez, 84
  • SP Taijuan Walker, 62

Lineup

1: SS Trea Turner, 95
2: DH Kyle Schwarber, 87
3: 1B Bryce Harper, 89
4: 3B Alec Bohm, 78
5: C J.T. Realmuto, 81
6: RF Nick Castellanos, 70
7: 2B Bryson Stott, 85
8: CF Brandon Marsh, 79
9: LF Harrison Bader, 84

Average Overall

  • Starting pitchers: 77.8
  • Starting lineup: 83.1
  • Full team: 77.6

6: Milwaukee Brewers

Pitchers

  • SP Freddy Peralta, 88
  • SP Jose Quintana, 73
  • SP Quinn Priester, 79
  • SP Chad Patrick, 72
  • SP Jacob Misiorowski, 80

Lineup

1: LF Jackson Chourio, 85
2: 2B Brice Turang, 93
3: C William Contreras, 82
4: DH Christian Yelich, 84
5: 1B Andrew Vaughn, 73
6: RF Sal Frelick, 83
7: 3B Caleb Durbin, 77
8: CF Black Perkins, 77
9: SS Joey Ortiz, 74

Average Overall

  • Starting pitchers: 76.7
  • Starting lineup: 80.9
  • Full team: 80

7: Toronto Blue Jays

Pitchers

  • SP Kevin Gausman, 87
  • SP Shane Bieber, 84
  • SP Trey Yesavage, 73
  • SP Eric Lauer, 73

Lineup

1: DH George Springer, 95
2: LF Davis Schneider, 76
3: 1B Vladimir Guerrero Jr., 88
4: C Alejandro Kirk, 88
5: CF Daulton Varsho, 88
6: 3B Ernie Clement, 82
7: RF Anthony Santander, 72
8: 2B Isiah Kiner-Falefa, 72
9: SS Andres Gimenez, 80

Average Overall

  • Starting pitchers: 79.3
  • Starting lineup: 82.3
  • Full team: 77.2

8: Detroit Tigers

Pitchers

  • SP Tarik Skubal, 99
  • SP Jack Flaherty, 80
  • SP Casey Mize, 80
  • SP Keider Montero, 68

Lineup

1: 2B Gleyber Torres, 80
2: RF Kerry Carpenter, 80
3: LF Riley Greene, 83
4: 1B Spencer Torkelson, 83
5: DH Colt Keith, 73
6: C Dillon Dingler, 86
7: 3B Zach McKinstry, 81
8: SS Javier Baez, 79
9: CF Parker Meadows, 75

Average Overall

  • Starting pitchers: 81.8
  • Starting lineup: 80
  • Full team: 78.3

3. Conclusion

As evident from the ratings, each team possesses unique strengths and weaknesses that contribute to their playoff performance. For players looking to enhance their gameplay or explore different strategies within MLB The Show 25, purchasing MLB The Show cheap stubs can provide a significant advantage. Get ready to engage in the thrilling postseason with your favorite team on the virtual field!